RePallet Co.Denver · Circular by design
Get a quote

Guide · Grading

Pallet grades, defined properly

Every yard in the country uses the letters A and B. Almost none of them define them. Here is a practical written reference standard, and how to read any supplier's.

Request pricing

Everything marked with a star is required. The rest helps us quote faster.

Free to request
A working address, so a partner supplier can send your quote.
US or Canadian number.
Two-letter code such as CO, or the full name.
US ZIP or Canadian postal code.
Whole numbers only.
No phone tag — requests go to partner suppliers in our network. Fields marked * are required. See our privacy policy.

Pallet grades describe repair history and consistency, not raw strength. Grade A (#1) has original stringers and at most two replaced deck boards; Grade B (#2) permits companion stringers, plugs and up to four replaced boards; Grade C is a core — serviceable lumber rather than a serviceable pallet.

Grades are not an industry standard with legal force. They are a supplier's promise, which is why you should ask for the written definition before you order, from whichever partner supplier quotes you or from anyone else.

A reference grade standard

Reference grade standard for 48" x 40" GMA stringer pallets. Use it to compare suppliers, and confirm the partner supplier's own written standard on your quote.
CriterionPremium (A+)Grade A (#1)Grade B (#2)Core (C)
Replaced deck boards0≤ 2≤ 4Any
Companion stringersNoneNonePermittedPermitted
Stringer plugsNoneNonePermittedPermitted
Missing boardsNoneNoneNonePermitted
Top deck boards775 – 7Any
Colour and speciesMatchedMixed acceptableMixedAny
StainingNoneMinimalPermittedAny
Protruding fastenersNoneNoneNonePermitted
Mould or rotNoneNoneNoneRejected
RackingYesYesNoNo
AutomationYesYesNoNo
Every grade excludes the same things: mould bloom, rot, chemical staining, fire damage, live infestation and any pallet with a methyl-bromide (MB) stamp. Those are rejections, not downgrades.

What the terminology actually means

Companion stringer

A full-length board nailed and usually glued alongside a cracked stringer to restore its load path. Structurally effective and visually obvious. It adds thickness on one side, which is why companion-stringer pallets are unsuitable for conveyors and rack beams.

Plug

A shaped block routed into a damaged notch area and fastened in place. Repairs notch blow-out — the most common stringer failure on partial four-way pallets — without replacing the whole member.

Shiner

A nail that has backed out and is protruding, usually because it was smooth-shank rather than ring-shank. Shiners tear packaging, cut hands and jam automation. A properly graded pallet, at any grade, should have had shiners sheared or reset.

Lead board

The outermost deck board at each end. It takes the impact from fork entry and mis-set forks, so it fails first and is the most commonly replaced board on any pallet.

Core

A pallet bought as raw material rather than as a pallet. Cores feed a recycler's repair line. Selling a core as a Grade B is the single most common dishonesty in this industry.

Reading someone else's grades

Since grades are not legally defined, a supplier's "Grade A" can mean anything. Five questions will tell you what you are actually buying, and the way a supplier answers is as informative as the answers.

  1. How many replaced deck boards are permitted in this grade? A precise number is a good sign. "A few" is not.
  2. Are companion stringers allowed? This is the single biggest determinant of whether a pallet can be racked.
  3. Is the standard written down, and can I have a copy? If the answer is no, the grade is marketing.
  4. What happens if a load misses the grade? The answer should be swap or credit, with a stated window.
  5. Can I see photographs of the actual lot? Stock photography in a recycled-pallet quote is a red flag.

For a focused comparison of the two grades most people are choosing between, see Grade A vs Grade B.

Specifying grade by application

Grade recommendations by use. When in doubt, say how the pallets will be used in your quote request so the partner supplier can specify the grade.
ApplicationGradeWhy
Rack storageA or PremiumConsistent structure; unsupported span is unforgiving
Conveyors, AS/RS, robotic palletisingA or PremiumDimensional consistency; no companion stringers
Retail-facing deliveryA or PremiumAppearance is part of your brand
Floor stacking in your own warehouseBSound and lower cost
One-way outbound shippingBThe pallet will not come back
Internal movement between buildingsBLow risk, high volume
Dunnage and load stabilisingCoreStructure is barely loaded
Export with ISPM 15A, heat treatedA rejected container dwarfs the pallet cost

Grade vocabulary across the industry

The same pallet gets four different names depending on who is selling it. Use this translation table when two quotes use different terminology for what may be the same pallet.

Roughly equivalent grade terms in common use. Always ask for the written definition rather than trusting the label.
Reference gradeAlso calledRegional usageWhat it usually means
Premium / A+AA, Premium A, Number One PlusNationwideNo repairs at all, matched species
Grade A#1, A Grade, Grade One#1 in the east, A in the westOriginal stringers, minimal repair
Grade B#2, B Grade, Repaired#2 in the eastRepairs visible and permitted
CoreGrade C, Scrap, Cores, CullsNationwideRaw material, not a working pallet
—Combo, MixedNationwideUnsorted; whatever arrived
—EconomyMarketing termUsually B, sometimes core
—Recon, ReconditionedPlastic mostlyWashed and inspected
“Combo” and “Economy” are the ones to watch. Neither has a definition. A combo load is a mixed load, which may be fine if it is priced as one and a problem if it is priced as Grade B.

Grading recycled versus grading new

There is a structural difference that explains a lot of the confusion in this market. New-pallet quality is a manufacturing specification — you state what you want and it gets built. Recycled grade is a sorting decision about something that already exists.

Two different kinds of quality assurance.
New palletsRecycled pallets
Quality set bySpecificationSorting accuracy
Variation within a loadVery lowInherent; managed by grading
What you are buyingA build to specA promise about a sort
What can go wrongSpec not followedSorting not accurate
How to verifyMeasure against the specSample the load and check the standard
RemedyRebuild or replaceSwap or credit
The supplier's real skillProduction controlSort-line judgement

That last row is the point. When you choose a recycled pallet supplier, you are choosing a sorting operation. Ask what their sort accuracy is and how they measure it.

Auditing a delivered load in ten minutes

You do not need to inspect every pallet. You need a sample large enough to catch a systematically wrong load, which is smaller than people think.

  1. 1

    Pull 20 units at random

    From different parts of the trailer, not the top of the nearest stack. Twenty is plenty to catch a load that is a grade out.

  2. 2

    Check the structural criteria first

    Cracked stringers, missing boards, protruding fasteners. Any of these in a Grade A sample is a real finding.

  3. 3

    Count the repairs

    Replaced boards and companion stringers against the written standard for the grade you ordered.

  4. 4

    Set three down on a flat floor

    A pallet that rocks tells you something no visual check will.

  5. 5

    Photograph anything you find

    Two or three images with a tape measure settles the conversation instantly.

  6. 6

    Report promptly

    Check the window on the partner supplier's swap-or-credit policy, which should be stated on your quote, and report inside it.

What a sample of 20 tells you.
Finding in a Grade A sampleInterpretationAction
0 – 1 units marginalNormal variationAccept
2 – 3 units marginalBorderline sortNote it; mention it on the next order
4+ units marginalSystematically wrongReport and request a swap
Any cracked stringerShould not have passedReport immediately
Any mouldRejection criterionIsolate the load and report
Any companion stringerGrade B in a Grade A loadReport

Questions people actually ask

Is there an official pallet grading standard?
No legally binding one. There are widely used conventions — A/B and #1/#2 — but each supplier defines them. This is why written standards and swap-or-credit policies matter more than the letter itself.
What is a premium or A+ pallet?
A Grade A pallet with no repairs at all, usually with matched species and colour. Worth paying for when appearance matters; not worth paying for as a strength upgrade, because a repaired Grade A is not weaker.
Can a Grade B pallet be upgraded?
Only if the issue is deck boards. A companion stringer permanently defines a pallet as Grade B under the reference standard above, because the grade describes original structure rather than current strength.
Why do grades differ between suppliers?
Because nothing forces them to agree. A yard with a large repair capacity can afford a strict Grade A; a broker reselling unsorted loads cannot. Ask for the definition and compare like with like.
Should I ask for photographs before dispatch?
Yes. Many suppliers photograph each truckload before the doors close; ask the partner supplier on your quote whether they do. Photographs are the fastest way to settle any question about what was actually loaded.
Do grades mean the same thing across the country?
No. A yard in Ohio and a yard in Denver can both sell honest Grade A and mean different things by it, because there is no binding standard. Always compare written definitions, not letters.
Can I specify my own grade standard?
Yes, and large buyers sometimes do. Many suppliers will grade to your written standard as long as it is unambiguous and achievable from the stream they receive. Include it in your quote request so the partner supplier can confirm.
Why is there no official grading body?
Attempts have been made. The practical obstacle is that pallet condition is continuous rather than categorical, and regional supply differs enough that a single standard would be unachievable in some markets.
Does a stencil or a company mark affect grade?
Not structurally. If you want branding removed, many suppliers can plane, paint over or saw off the marked area — flag it up front in your request, because it is usually a small charge and a large embarrassment if missed.
How often do loads miss grade?
It varies by supplier and by how tightly the grade is defined. Ask the partner supplier how disputes are handled and what evidence they need; a clear written standard and a stated swap-or-credit window matter more than any headline figure.

Let's keep your pallets in the loop

Whether you have 40 broken cores behind the dock or need 4,000 Grade A pallets a month, the conversation starts the same way.